Paul is the only person in Big Brother history to lose two finals by one vote, and he did it in consecutive summers. Nicole F beat him 5–4 in Big Brother 18. Josh beat him 5–4 in Big Brother 19. Five other runners-up have lost a final by a single vote, but nobody else has done it twice.
- Seasons: Big Brother 18 in 2016 and Big Brother 19 in 2017, back to back.
- Result both times: runner-up, 5–4.
- Beaten by: Nicole F, then Josh.
- Head of Household: in both seasons, including the final HOH of Big Brother 18.
- Never evicted: he reached the final two in both of his seasons.
- The record: seven seasons have been decided by one vote. Two of them are his.
Big Brother 18: one vote short
He was on the block in the very first week and still never went home. Frank’s Roadkill nomination put him up alongside Paulie and Jozea; Paul won the veto himself and came down, and Bridgette went up in his place. The next week he was nominated again and Paulie used the veto on him, which sent Victor out instead. He took Head of Household in week six, came off the block on another veto in week nine with Corey going up behind him, and sat on the block again in weeks ten and twelve without losing either vote.
Then he won Head of Household at the final four, and won the final Head of Household after that, and evicted James to choose his seat. He picked Nicole F. The jury gave it to her by one.
Big Brother 19: the same ending
He came back the next summer with a three-week safety grant, which voided Cody’s attempt to nominate him in week one. He took Head of Household in week two and sent Cody out. He used the veto to move the target twice more in the back half, won Head of Household at the final four again, and reached the final two again.
What makes the season sting is that the other finalist had said it out loud, days earlier, on the feeds.
Josh: “I think I have a better chance against Paul in the final 2.”
He was right. Josh took it by one vote, and Paul had lost the same way twelve months apart.
His read on finale day was that the returning player carries the loss before the game even begins.
Paul: “The second I walked through those doors I was immediately put at a disadvantage.”
Why the two losses matter
Twenty-six jury seasons have produced four unanimous wins and seven finals decided by a single vote. Paul owns two of those seven; nobody else owns more than one. Whatever else is arguable about how he played, the record itself is not: he reached the last night twice and was beaten by the smallest margin the game has, both times.