Big Brother 6: Winner, Cast and the Season That Split the House

Big Brother 6 is the season the house split in half and never came back together. Fourteen houseguests entered in July 2005, each secretly paired with somebody they already knew, and within three weeks the game had hardened into two alliances that despised each other — the Sovereign Six on one side, the group that called itself the Friendship and everybody else called the Nerd Herd on the other. Maggie won it 4–3. Twenty years on it is still the season most often named the best the show has produced.

Who won Big Brother 6?

Maggie won Big Brother 6 on 20 September 2005, beating Ivette 4–3 for $500,000. Ivette took the runner-up prize of $50,000.

The result turned on a decision Ivette made an hour earlier. She won the final Head of Household, and with Janelle — the last Sovereign standing, and by some distance the most popular player left — sitting beside her, she cut her. That handed the jury a choice between two members of the same alliance, and the jury gave it to Maggie by one vote.

• Aired: 7 July to 20 September 2005 on CBS.
• Houseguests: 14, entering as seven secret pairs.
• The twist: the Summer of Secrets — every houseguest already knew one other person in the house.
• The prize: $500,000 and $50,000. A $1,000,000 top prize was on offer, but only if both halves of one pair reached the final two — which never happened.
• Returning player: Kaysar, voted back in by the public, then evicted again a week later.
• Double evictions: two, in weeks 7 and 9.
• The house: newly rebuilt for this season on the CBS lot, on the stage where Yes, Dear had been filmed.

What was the Summer of Secrets twist?

Every houseguest walked in with a secret partner — a friend, an ex-roommate, a sibling-in-all-but-name from their life outside. The catch was that each pair was told they were the only pair. Viewers were let in on all seven on the first live show; the house had to work it out for itself, and did, faster than production can have hoped.

If both halves of a single pair made it to the final two, the prize doubled to $1,000,000 with $250,000 for the runner-up. No pair got close.

The seven secret pairs

• April and Jennifer — sorority sisters.
• Ashlea and Janelle — former roommates.
• Beau and Ivette — former co-workers.
• Eric and Maggie — friends.
• Howie and Rachel — friends.
• James and Sarah — dating.
• Kaysar and Michael — neighbours.

James was originally cast with a friend called Mike, who withdrew before the season started. Sarah replaced him, which is why the house went in with eight women and six men rather than an even split.

The Sovereign Six and the Nerd Herd

The season’s shape was set in week three and never really changed.

• The Sovereign Six — Kaysar, Janelle, Howie, Rachel, James and Sarah. Named by Kaysar when he built it during his week-three Head of Household.
• The Friendship — Eric, Maggie, Ivette, April, Jennifer and Beau. That was their own name for it. The other side called them the Nerd Herd, and that is the name that stuck.

The Friendship lost its founder in week three and won almost everything afterwards. Every member of the Sovereign Six except Janelle was gone by the end of week nine, and Janelle only lasted as long as she did by winning competitions at a rate nobody else in the house came close to.

Big Brother 6 week by week

Kaysar was evicted twice and voted back once

No storyline defines this season better. Kaysar built the Sovereign Six, won the week-three Head of Household, and was gone by week four. Then the public got a vote.

He came back with 82% of it — more than four million votes out of over five million cast, a margin that told CBS exactly how the audience felt about which side of the house it was watching. He walked back in during the Pressure Cooker night.

Seven days later he was evicted 7–0.

The mechanism was a deal Jennifer had made and broke. She had promised Kaysar that if he let her take the Head of Household, she would not nominate him. She won it, nominated Rachel and Janelle instead, and when Rachel came down off the block with the veto she put Kaysar up in her place. It is the single most-cited broken deal in the season, and it is why the Sovereign Six spent the back half of the summer with nothing left but Janelle.

The fights

Big Brother 6 is remembered for the hostility as much as the gameplay, and it started early.

Week two, Eric and Michael. Rachel told Eric she had overheard Michael making a joke about Eric’s grandparents. Eric confronted him in the backyard that evening. Michael called him a midget, in rather more words than that, and Eric went at him before the other houseguests got between them. No punches landed; Kaysar was the one who pulled Eric back. Production sent Eric to the diary room and Michael to the storage room. Eric apologised to the house afterwards, and Michael was evicted that week.

A second confrontation broke out inside the same incident, between Ivette and Kaysar, and production separated them too. What aired framed that half of it as an argument about respect for women. What the feeds carried, and the broadcast did not, was different.

Week six, Howie and April. Howie spent the better part of two days on April — her dog, her husband, and the nickname Busto, which he did not let go of. Janelle spent the same week going after Maggie, Jennifer and April over the Kaysar backdoor.

Week seven, Janelle and Beau. Janelle won Head of Household and delivered the line the season is quoted for — “Give me the key, b—-tch” — then nominated Jennifer and Maggie with “Bye bye, b—-tches.” Later that week, after the house won alcohol in a competition, she and Beau got into a scuffle that turned physical enough for the others to break it up. She called him a gold-digging w—-e; he called her a polyester-haired b—-tch.

Week nine, April and the viewers. When Julie Chen announced that America had voted Janelle a phone call from Michael, April called the audience pieces of s— on the feeds and accused the producers of rigging the show.

What the feeds carried and the broadcast cut

Across roughly six weeks, from mid-July into late August, Ivette repeatedly made remarks about Kaysar’s religion and background on the live feeds — comparing his gameplay to a suicide bombing, calling him a fake Muslim, and referring to him as a terrorist often enough that other houseguests were still trying to work out weeks later who had started it. Maggie’s own reaction to hearing it repeated back was that it was racist. On at least one occasion production cut the feeds to fish mid-sentence.

None of it aired. That was a deliberate decision, and the show’s executive producer said so on the record at the time: “Racial or religious slurs did not end up on the television show. We and CBS do not want to put those kind of comments on national television.” He also described this cast as the most divisive the show had ever had.

It is worth being precise about what this does and does not mean. The broadcast was not sanitising conflict generally — the Eric and Michael confrontation aired close to how it happened, and the Jennifer betrayal aired accurately. One specific category of content was removed, and the network confirmed the policy in its own words.

Why Big Brother 6 is still rated so highly

Four things, mostly.

The house divided cleanly and early, which almost never happens — most seasons the lines blur. The feeds were relentless, because two groups who genuinely disliked each other were locked in together for ten weeks. Janelle turned into the competition player the format had not really seen before her, winning when winning was the only thing keeping her in. And the audience got a say, used it on Kaysar, and watched the house overturn the decision inside a week.

CBS agreed. Four of these houseguests — Kaysar, James, Janelle and Howie, all Sovereign Six — were brought back the following summer for Big Brother 7 All-Stars. Not one member of the Friendship was invited.

Related Pages